Hourigan
Created with Sketch.
4 min read

The Developer’s Guide to Site Selection: Balancing Vision and Practicality

08.28.24

Real estate development is the act of transforming property (often raw land) with labor, capital, and entrepreneurship. As a former and retired start-up lawyer and 20+ year real estate developer, I believe there are few endeavors as entrepreneurial as property development. Reduced to one sentence, the essence of property development is the ability to identify a need/demand for a specific property in a good location and a willingness to take the risk to make a profit. 

In real estate development, the selection of a project’s site is one of the most critical decisions, as it fundamentally shapes the project’s feasibility, profitability, and overall success.

In real estate development, the selection of a project’s site is one of the most critical decisions, as it fundamentally shapes the project’s feasibility, profitability, and overall success.  For context, Warren Buffett, arguably the world’s greatest investor, famously said the most important decision you can make for your personal success is who you marry. As it relates to real estate investment success, site selection is the equivalent of who you marry. It is one of the most critical strategic planning decisions for any property investment. 

The Importance of Location 

In addition to being the most used phrase in real estate, ‘Location, Location, Location’ is a complicated set of decisions for any successful real estate project. The location of a site determines its accessibility, attractiveness, and potential for future growth. For instance, a commercial data center might thrive near major fiber optic routes and power sources, while a multi-story office or apartment building benefits from proximity to public transportation and urban amenities. Assessing the surrounding infrastructure and understanding the local market dynamics are essential first steps in site selection.  

Aerial image of a development site.
Captured from above, this aerial shot of Deepwater Industrial Park in Richmond, VA highlights its strategic location—just 2.2 miles from the Richmond Port Terminal and with high visibility from Interstate 95. Chosen for its proximity to key logistics hubs, this site positions businesses within a day’s drive of over 40% of the U.S. population, making it an emerging powerhouse in Mid-Atlantic trade and logistics.

Zoning and Regulatory Constraints 

The labyrinth of zoning laws and regulatory constraints needs to be navigated adeptly. Zoning laws dictate what can be built and where, influencing everything from building height to usage types. A deep dive into local regulations and the regional comprehensive plan can reveal potential hurdles or opportunities, such as zoning variances or incentives for sustainable development. Engaging with local authorities early in the process can provide valuable insights and pave the way for smoother approvals.  

Environmental and Site Conditions 

A thorough understanding of the site’s environmental conditions is imperative. This includes assessing soil quality, topography, flood risk, and potential contamination. For example, a site with poor soil conditions may require extensive (and expensive) foundation work, while a location in a flood-prone area might necessitate additional mitigation measures. Conducting environmental assessments and geotechnical studies can uncover these hidden challenges and inform the feasibility of the project.  

Market Demand and Demographics 

Market demand and demographic trends should guide the vision for any development project. Analyzing population growth, income levels, and lifestyle preferences can help determine the type of development that will be most successful. For instance, an advanced manufacturing facility might not be viable in an area lacking skilled labor or appropriate infrastructure. Tailoring the project to meet the needs and desires of the local population can significantly enhance its marketability and success

Infrastructure and Accessibility 

The availability and quality of infrastructure can make or break a development project. Adequate road networks, public transport, utilities, and broadband connectivity are essential for modern developments. Evaluating the existing infrastructure and planning for any required upgrades or extensions is crucial. For example, a tech campus would require robust digital infrastructure, while a logistics hub would prioritize excellent road and rail connections.  

Aerial image of a medical office building under construction.

Overlooking the construction site of the new OrthoVirginia Westchester building in the heart of Midlothian, VA, this aerial view showcases the strategic positioning adjacent to other medical services and easy access from Route 60—ensuring seamless integration into the community’s healthcare landscape.

 

Financial Viability 

Ultimately, the financial viability of a site is paramount. This involves land acquisition costs and expenses related to site preparation, construction, and ongoing maintenance. A detailed financial analysis, including potential revenue streams and return on investment, can help determine whether a site is worth pursuing. Securing funding and managing budgets effectively are critical components of this analysis.  

Community Impact and Engagement 

The impact of the development on the local community and the importance of community engagement cannot be overstated. Understanding and addressing community concerns, such as displacement, traffic congestion, and environmental impact, can foster goodwill and support for the project. Engaging with community leaders and stakeholders early in the process can help identify potential issues and collaboratively develop solutions.  

The Bottom Line 

Successful property development requires a good site selection process. Data analytics have improved so much in my career that you could be fooled to think site selection has become a 0 and 1 algorithm. Like most things in this world, it is more complicated than a single variable. A lot like who you marry! 

 

Back to Projects